Washblog

City of Seattle to pay $1 million for illegal arrests at WTO protest - is it enough?

It took seven long years, but justice was finally served thanks to the aptly named team of Public Justice working on behalf of approximately 175 people who were found to have been wrongly arrested at the WTO protests.

In a landmark settlement reached by Public Justice on behalf of scores of people arrested in 1999 while peacefully protesting the World Trade Organization, the City of Seattle has agreed to seal and expunge the records of what a jury earlier determined to be their unconstitutional arrests by Seattle police.

In addition, the settlement mandates that the City improve police training in order to prevent unconstitutional mass arrests in the future. Finally, the City will pay $1 million to compensate the protesters for the violation of their constitutional rights and the costs of bringing the lawsuit.

The best news of all, however, is not that these people got a few grand each, but that the City has agreed to incorporate key court rulings - that the police lacked probable cause - into police training.

Diamondstone noted that the settlement serves "an important lesson for police departments around the country that have looked to Seattle's WTO experience" when large numbers of protesters gather in other large cities. "The proper lesson is to avoid repetition of the fiasco in Seattle by allowing peaceful protesters to gather, as guaranteed by the Constitution," Diamondstone said.

This is all putting it mildly.  I suggest to get an idea of what really happened at the WTO protests in Seattle, you check out pics like this one:

That would be the Seattle police opening fire upon protestors at point blank range.  Rubber bullets at that range can maim and kill as well as permanently disfigure and blind.

So now all is well with the world right?  Our Constitution has been reaffirmed and this kind of stuff won't happen anymore right?

RIGHT?

Yeah, right.  This is standard operating procedure for the police force at every city the WTO meets.  At the last WTO protest, 800 protestors were locked up in Hong Kong when the police stepped in to suppress their voices.

That's pretty much the way it goes anywhere the WTO goes.  

How about here in our own state of Washington?  The jury found the protestors were unconstitutionally arrested late January.  Between then and now have we seen any signs that Washington State police officers have learned to respect the Constitution of the United States?

I think not.

Forty-six seconds after protesters begin to chant "Shame on you!" at the police in response to something that cannot be seen in the video, and just as the situation seems to be calming down, police open fire and advance into the crowd firing rapid-fire weapons.  --  One man is seen shot in the head.  --  Protesters are clubbed.  --  The firing at the unarmed, unresisting protestors goes on for almost 25 seconds.  --  Intrepid videographers stand there, filming the scene.  --  As the shooting stops, one riot police officer continues stand over a wounded young  women and prevents others from coming to her assistance for 30 seconds.

This is the way things happen in a fascist police state where corporations are protected and citizens are attacked.  That it took SEVEN YEARS to hand down todays verdict speaks volumes about how difficult it is to find justice where the police are involved.

As for the police officers who defended the WTO corporatists and deprived its own people of their fundamental rights?  Not one of them was ever reprimanded or disciplined by the city.

Like illegally arresting protestors wherever the WTO goes, not punishing police for their own crimes is standard operating procedure.  

$1 million is chump change to the WTO.  The City of Seattle should have been made to pay a LOT more because what they took was more than a few days freedom from a few protestors, they took what Americans have shed their blood for.  They took freedom from ALL of us.  And they then took seven years to face up to it.  The penalty for that should have been so harsh that no American city would ever contemplate doing this again.

< WA State Impeachment Summary: Conversation with Linda Boyd | Rep. DeBolt: crazy guy in the room >

Poll

How much do you think the City should have paid?
Nothing, they were keeping the peace
$1 million sounds about right
$10 million would have sent a stronger message
$100 million would set a precedent no city could afford to ignore
Just hand over Safeco field and call it even

Votes: 6
Results | Other Polls
Display: Sort:
thanks for posting on it.

It's so timely, given what's going on in Tacoma.

I don't have an opinion on whether this is a high enough settlement related to the severity of the violation.  But I think it's enough to serve as a deterrant to Tacoma and other cities.  It's got to be balanced out as well, so that the payment made by the city is not more of a burden on the people of Seattle than it is an 'encouragement' to Seattle and other jurisdictions to appropriately respond to protests.  

It's always a push-pull, isn't it, between democracy and anti-democratic forces.  We're in a time when democracy is under seige -- but we're fighting back...  

by noemie maxwell on Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 12:09:21 AM PST

* 1 none 0 *


trust funds.

what if we all had a 1/2 a million? that is 1000 hours of 500 bucks an hour lawyers/ lobbyists.

if 3 or 30 or 30,000 of us put some of our hours together, we got a chance to have a chance against the scumbags.

what is better about my idea than us all kicking in 30 bucks to the Dems or some union,

AND then we gotta pick 'leaders' AND they gotta include us AND they gotta keep their jobs AND they gotta keep us in the dark

my idea is better cuz if a bunch of us get together, and the ONLY deliverables we're getting is freaking excuses and our lawyer / lobbyists eating caviar and swilling chivas

we can stop payment / fire the bastards immediately.

look, leaders are for hire, this would just give us peeee-ons some freaking leverage to hire the best for our interests.

rmm.

http://www.liemail.com/BambooGrassroots.html

by rmdSeaBos on Mon Apr 16, 2007 at 08:22:50 PM PST

* 2 none 0 *