Washblog

The Mormon Question

This is meant to be more of a question than a long statement, but the media's total Romney Rollover suggests we do have to get a very few facts on the table.

First fact: There are a lot of great, patriotic and Progressive Mormons and the LDS church has been a great community-builder in this country. We have some wonderful people among our local Dems who are LDS members.  

Second fact: We live in a country that has always demanded the highest level of secularism in its government. Mormonism could probably only have developed here in America for exactly that reason.

Third fact: Mormons have some ideas inherent in their faith that are disturbing to Progressive, secular values and which tend to threaten even some important American values.

Fourth fact: Mormonism is highly structured, thus Mormons act practically on their values and the Mormon idea of a scripturally-based hierarchy extends from God, through Salt Lake City, right into every Mormon home. This makes it more important to understand a Mormon political leader's faith than it is to understand the faith of most political leaders, in my view. Where there are large numbers of Mormons, government and the LDS church are often very close.

Fifth fact: Mitt Romney has been consistently dishonest about his Mormon faith and has failed to publically recognize legitimate questions.

Sixth fact: Mormonism is an entirely new confession of Christianity, based on post-Christian Scriptures and claiming to be a re-incarnation of the one, true Christian church that is growing rapidly.

So we have a new church full of nice people. They have some strange books and customs, but we allow for the here in the U.S. and so of course Mormons are welcome here.

What we don't allow are legal racism, legal sexism, and the unification of Church and state.

Unfortunately, the LDS church professed a scriptural belief in racism until 1978. 1978 is not very long ago. For a new religion, Mormonism changed its mind about race very late in the game indeed. And the LDS leadership changed its mind through divine revelation and this became the law of the Mormon church immediately after its announcement. That was because the Mormon "prophet" and his "twelve apostles" declared their absolute authority on the matter once they used that word "revelation".

Mormonism is no longer racist, but it is devoutly and completely sexist - from the top of the LDS church, into the Mormon home. Men are the spiritual leaders of women - even the women who taught those very men in Sunday school (in effect, taught them to be Mormons in the first place). Sons even become the spiritual leaders of their mothers.

All this comes from an odd type of absolutism, forced on the Mormon church by its history as a sect of outsiders trying to re-create a new Judeo-Christianity in America according to divine revelation and predestination. It begins with Smith's revelation about the "war of heaven" and other "pre-mortal" models for how the Earth should be. It goes through to Smith's revelation that God himself is somehow male and so on and so forth on through America as a new Zion.

And it is this last one that I find particularly disturbing. America is a Mormon holy land and they believe that when the Savior comes back he will rule from here - at least part of the time. And that belief, I think, has to be examined if it is held by a person who has the military authority and technological capacity to destroy the world or a good part of it.

And Mormons have a history of excommunicating their members for less offense than one might suppose signing a bill or treaty that goes against the teachings of Mormonism.

And since every single Mormon male is an authority on the church and since Mitt Romney is a high authority in his church, I think it's entirely reasonable to ask more about Mormonism before electing a Mormon to the presidency.

Unfortunately, there seems to be a mood prevailing AMONG LIBERALS that somehow questions about the LDS church are off-limits.

< Whatcom County Agricultural Workers Found Coopertiva Jacal: A Cooperative Organic Farm | Dane Keane busted again!! >

Poll

Is Romney's Mormonism Fair Game?
Yes.
No.

Votes: 19
Results | Other Polls
Display: Sort:
You claim above that "Mitt Romney has been consistently dishonest about his Mormon faith..." I've followed pretty closely Romney's comments; and as a long time Mormon, I haven't seen where he's been dishonest at all (kind of rules out "consistently"). Do you have a couple of such instances demonstrating how he's lied about his faith? I'd be interested to see where you think he has been dishonest.

by Alma on Wed Dec 19, 2007 at 06:09:26 PM PST

* 1 none 0 *


I don't care what arcane point of Mormon doctrine Romney believes or doesn't believe, whether the second coming of Christ will happen in Jerusalem, Salt Lake City, or Santiago.

I do care that he's unable to confirm his belief in the separation of church and state (as did John Kennedy), instead spouting fuzzy rhetoric like "Freedom requires religion and religion requires freedom". What the hell does that mean?

What about the right to be free from government-sponsored religious doctrine, where does that fit in? Are unbelievers citizens with equal rights or not?

Not to mention his stated intention to "double the size of Guantanamo". Now that's something Jesus would surely approve of.

by dinazina on Fri Dec 21, 2007 at 07:56:22 PM PST

* 4 none 0 *



Mormons see America's role in the world as based in prophecy. That is very threatening to a secular America. Atheists, Muslims, satanists, Wiccans and scientologists are not viable politically. Why should Mormons be? Why do Mormons get a free pass?

Mormonism is a new religion that is developing OUT of its original cult-like history. It has a lot of growing to do, to say the least.

Part of what the "new atheism" is accomplishing is bringing atheists (like me) out of the closet. I don't see how it's even marginally unfair, unreasonable or anything but positive for Mormons to come out of the closet. Mitt Romney CHOSE Mormonism, as every Mormon does. We have every reason to question that choice - one of the most important and central in his life, according to Romney himself.

Liberals who take a "hands off" attitude about Romney's Mormonism are not championing religious freedom. They are ignoring threats to religious freedom.

by dlaw on Fri Jan 04, 2008 at 09:45:12 PM PST

<DI