On Protecting The Innocent, Or, Is There A Death Penalty Compromise?

I don't feel very good about this country this morning, and as so many of us are I'm thinking of how Troy Davis was hustled off this mortal coil by the State of Georgia without a lot of thought of what it means to execute the innocent.

And given the choice, I'd rather see us abandon the death penalty altogether, for reasons that must, at this moment, seem self-evident; that said, it's my suspicion that a lot of states are not going to be in any hurry to abandon their death penalties anytime soon now that they know the Supreme Court will allow the innocent to be murdered.

So what if there was a way to create a compromise that balanced the absolute need to protect the innocent with the feeling among many Americans that, for some crimes, we absolutely have to impose the death penalty?

Considering the circumstances, it's not going to be an easy subject, but let's give it a try, and see what we can do.

Let's Fix An Error Dept.: Apologies are in order, because in our last story we identified The Riverside Church in Manhattan as the place where George Carlin learned to be Catholic - and that could not have been more incorrect.  Bad research was the culprit here, and it's something that we'll obviously be working to improve. So, once again: sorry, and my bad.

Now if all the states want to limit the imposition of the death penalty to just the guilty (and after what we just saw in Georgia, that's no longer 100% certain), one way you could do it would be to make it a lot harder to prove guilt - and that's what we have in mind for today's proposal.

As you may recall, we convict today with a "burden of proof" that is described as "guilt beyond a reasonable doubt"; as we now know, it is possible to prove guilt, beyond a reasonable doubt, even when there's a whole lot of reasonable doubt to be found.

In Davis' case, he was given a chance on appeal to prove his innocence, and despite this conclusion from the Judge hearing the case...

"Ultimately, while Mr. Davis's new evidence casts some additional, minimal doubt on his conviction, it is largely smoke and mirrors..."

...Davis was still executed.

So the way I would get at this problem would be to change the burden of proof in these cases: if you want to execute someone who is facing an aggravated murder or other capital charge, instead of "guilt beyond a reasonable doubt", I would require "guilt beyond all doubt".

If you can't get to guilt beyond all doubt, but you can prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, then you could impose no sentence harsher than life without parole.

If this proposal had been in effect in Davis' case, there could have been no execution after he argued that he was denied the effective assistance of counsel, because that would have erased "all doubt"; after that he would have had the rest of his life to demonstrate that he was wrongly convicted.

There are going to be a few reasons people might not like this proposal, and I'll try to address some of them briefly:

Right off the bat, many will complain that because of the new burden of proof it will be virtually impossible to have executions at all; I would tell those folks that if that were to occur...then the system is working. The entire purpose of this plan is to make executions an extraordinarily rare occurrence and to move just about everyone on Death Rows nationwide to a "life without parole" future.

Beyond that, many will say that capital punishment is morally unacceptable under any circumstances, and to those folks I would respond that y'all make a pretty good point...but at the moment there are a lot of Americans who do not hold that moral position - and they have strong feelings too - and unless we can move them to a different point of view, then the best chance we have to prevent the innocent from being executed is to find some sort of compromise like this one.

(Don't believe me about that "strong feelings" thing? How many of the readers here would be OK with the death penalty for Osama Bin Laden, if he were proved "beyond all doubt" to have been the person behind 9/11?)

A similar line of thought is expressed in the idea that we are seeing more and more voters who do oppose capital punishment, and with a bit of patience, this problem will go away.

After what happened to Troy Davis, I think there's more urgency now than there was in times past, and that's because we now see that at least one State will quickly kill a prisoner in order to "clear the case", suggesting to me that patience is not as good an option as it was before.

Finally, I suspect many will feel that the effort to pass a proposal like this one would distract from the effort to end the death penalty, which is, again, a pretty good argument.

To those folks I would respond that we may get some states to end the death penalty today, but there are a lot of other states that are not going to want to give up the death penalty for some time to come (remember the people who cheered Rick Perry's execution record?), and if we aren't going to be able to end the death penalty completely, then I think we have to offer some sort of compromise; a compromise based on the concepts of "killing the innocent isn't The American Way" or "you could still execute Osama" could appeal to voters who simply won't give up on the death penalty altogether.

So that's what we have for you today: even though I personally would prefer that we end the death penalty and just go to life without parole for all these crimes, I don't think we're going to achieve that in a lot of states; with that in mind I'm proposing a compromise that would protect the innocent by ending virtually all executions, even as it allows an extraordinarily difficult to reach exception that could satisfy those who absolutely do not want to see the application of the death penalty come to an end.

It's an imperfect compromise, I'll admit - but in a big ol' swath of America that runs from roughly Florida to Idaho, it may be the best compromise we can make right now, and right now, in those places, that might have to be good enough.

Entirely Off The Subject Dept.: We are still trying to get signatures for the petition to change the name of Manhattan's W 121st St (one block from Seminary Row) to George Carlin Street, and we need your help; you can sign right here. The goal is to reach 10,000 signatures by Monday, so...get to it.
< On Fixing The World, Or, Help George Carlin Stick It To God | On The Question Of Virginity, Or, "Starter? I Can't Make Her Stop!" >


we can end it now: no compromise, no way
it can be ended...eventually, mostly
in many states this may be our best shot
sadly, nothing will end the death penalty
i support the status quo

Votes: 6
Results | Other Polls
Display: Sort:
Will wonders ever cease? Muscle Rip X is perfect for Muscle Rip X. It only further prolonged the inevitable. This was Muscle Rip X as far as the eye can see. I'm not advocating that anybody stop using Muscle Rip X. What I have to talk about is not as that respects Muscle Rip X, but rather the philosophy behind Muscle Rip X.

by RovelynRlapate on Sat Aug 18, 2012 at 04:42:09 AM PST

* 1 none 0 *

On Sunday night you will have to relax with Green Coffee Bean Extracts. This is how to eliminate Green Coffee Bean Extracts problems. Aren't you worried? This has all you have to do in order to enjoy your Green Coffee Bean Extracts. I don't play this and green Coffee Bean Extracts reviews are also popular to write about online. We'll discover how to use Green Coffee Bean Extracts. I make the rules around here. That is automatic. When all is said and done that's the way things are with Green Coffee Bean Extracts.
http://www.zimbio.com/Weight+Loss/articles/1KwjQO1EBQG/Green+Coffee+Bean+Extract+Review+Natural+Weig ht

by MiselintSmac on Mon Sep 17, 2012 at 08:37:32 AM PST

* 2 none 0 *

  • good by yogesh, 03/30/2015 10:17:40 PM PST (none / 0)
  • good by yogesh, 03/30/2015 10:39:23 PM PST (none / 0)
I couldn't come up with anything more revolutionary than this hypothesis in respect to, Vydox Male Enhancement. This is difficult and can be a poor way to do that with Vydox Male Enhancement.

by goieerwoeicoi on Tue Oct 09, 2012 at 08:39:53 AM PST

* 3 none 0 *

The death penalty was a penalty for some crimes under English basic law, and it was implemented in the majority of the American settlements before the Declaration of Independence. The techniques for execution and the unlawful acts subject to the death penalty shift by state and have changed over the long haul. For any writing help you can use this best essays for better support.

by Chrisatorain on Mon Mar 02, 2015 at 09:57:50 PM PST

* 4 none 0 *

I have heard about essay dutys however do nay experience many about them. I have decipher the previous inform moreover I obligation agree I sense again conversant than I was previously. smart custom writing interior small attention or do I have to provide sufficient term?

by jackdon on Sun Mar 22, 2015 at 01:16:12 AM PST

* 5 none 0 *

After i should be mindful that lots of folks has a special form to publish the knowledge, additionally I need to show sorts write-up definitely seems to be excellent. 电动马达

by yogesh on Fri Mar 27, 2015 at 04:53:16 AM PST

* 6 none 0 *

The entire resolution of this conception is to fabricate killings an extraordinarily exclusive episode also to drop righteous about everyone on Loss Fights nationwide to a "vivacity lacking parole" hereafter. SEX CLUBS

by sana on Mon Apr 20, 2015 at 04:36:10 AM PST

* 9 none 0 *

Really outstanding choice of music appropriate material found here. I found very useful history in this website which is possible only due to do their best. gym mats retail

by Kamille7 on Thu Apr 23, 2015 at 09:57:20 PM PST

* 11 none 0 *

The complete subject areas massive falsehoods is often robust other than health care medical diagnosis might be definitely definitely decorous. Know that will probably using your current. Fashion Jewelry Online

by sana on Sat Apr 25, 2015 at 05:14:53 AM PST

* 12 none 0 *

Very interesting post about protecting the innocent or a penalty compromise information shared here...industrial rubber flooring

by Anderson12 on Mon Apr 27, 2015 at 04:03:44 AM PST

* 13 none 0 *

Display: Sort:






Make a new account


Recommended Diaries

Washblog RSS Feeds

Political Contacts

Local Media

Coastal/Grays Harbor
Aberdeen Daily World
Chinook Observer
Montesano Vidette
Pacific County Press
Willapa Harbor Herald
KXRO 1320 AM

Olympic Peninsula
Peninsula Daily News
Bremerton Sun
Bremerton Chronicle
Gig Harbor Gateway
Port Orchard Independent
Port Townsend Leader
North Kitsap Herald
Squim Gazette
Central Kitsap Reporter
Business Examiner
KONP 1450 AM

Sound and Islands
Anacortes American
Bainbridge Review
Voice Of Bainbridge
San Juan Journal
The Islands' Sounder
Whidbey NewsTimes
South Whidbey Record
Stanwood/Camano News
Vashon Beachcomber
Voice Of Vashon
KLKI 1340 AM

North Puget Sound
Bellingham Herald
The Northern Light
Everett Herald
Skagit Valley Herald
Lynden Tribune
The Enterprise
Snohomish County Tribune
Snohomish County Business Journal
The Monroe Monitor
The Edmonds Beacon
KELA 1470 AM
KRKO 1380 AM

Central Puget Sound
King County Journal
Issaquah Press
Mukilteo Beacon
Voice of the Valley
Federal Way Mirror
Bothell/Kenmore Reporter
Kirkland courier
Mercer Island Reporter
Woodinville Weekly

Greater Seattle
Seattle PI
Seattle Times
UW Daily
The Stranger
Seattle Weekly
Capitol Hill Times
Madison Park Times
Seattle Journal of Commerce
NW Asian Weekly
West Seattle Herald
North Seattle Herald-Outlook
South Seattle Star
Magnolia News
Beacon Hill News
KOMO AM 1000
KEXP 90.3 FM
KUOW 94.9 FM
KVI 570 AM

South Puget Sound
The Columbian
Longview Daily News
Nisqually Valley News
Lewis County News
The Reflector
Eatonville Dispatch
Tacoma News Tribune
Tacoma Weekly
Puyallup Herald
Enumclaw Courier-Herald
The Olympian
KAOS 89.3 FM
KOWA FM 106.5
UPN 11

Ellensburg Daily Record
Levenworth Echo
Cle Elum Tribune
Snoqualmie Valley Record
Methow Valley News
Lake Chelan Mirror
Omak chronicle
The Newport Miner

The Spokesman-Review
KREM 2 TV Spokane
KXLY News 4 Spokane
KHQ 6 Spokane
KSPS Spokane
Othello Outlook
Cheney Free Press
Camas PostRecord
The South County sun
White Salmon Enterprise
Palouse Boomerang
Columbia Basin Herald
Grand Coulee Star
Walla Walla Union-Bulletin
Yakima Herald-Republic
KIMA 29 Yakima
KAPP TV 35 Yakima
KYVE Yakima
Wenatchee World
Tri-City Herald
TVEW TV 42 Tri-cities
KTNW Richland
KEPR 19 Pasco
Daily Sun News
Prosser Record-Bulletin
KTCR 1340 AM
KWSU Pullman
Moscow-Pullman Daily News