Dinesh D'Souza is a D'ouchebag

Cross-posted at Switzerblog.  Posting here 'cause Noemie is nice and invited me back and who can say no to Noemie?

Dinesh D'Souza takes the opportunity of the Virginia Tech massacre to write his odd and badly-reasoned screed, "Where is Atheism When Bad Things Happen?"  He opens thusly:

Notice something interesting about the aftermath of the Virginia Tech shootings? Atheists are nowhere to be found. Every time there is a public gathering there is talk of God and divine mercy and spiritual healing.

Yes, Dinesh, I notice that atheists are not prominently featured on the news in the aftermath of this horrible tragedy.  I also notice they aren't featured when things are going well, either.  Perhaps you're shocked that public gatherings after a tragedy take a godly tone - perhaps you've never seen a tragedy unfold before.  This is quite normal.  He continues:

To no one's surprise, [Richard] Dawkins has not been invited to speak to the grieving Virginia Tech community. What this tells me is that if it's difficult to know where God is when bad things happen, it is even more difficult for atheism to deal with the problem of evil.

No, atheism deals just as badly with the problem of evil as any group of believers.  What Dawkins' lack of an invitation to speak at Virginia Tech tells me is A) grieving people tend to look for some spiritual answer for their loss and hurt, and atheists don't pretend to give them those, B) Dawkins is British, and would have no reason to be invited to VT even if he was a godly man, and C) the people of Virginia Tech, unlike you, see no reason to inject a religious debate into an already difficult time.  

Is this seriously what you've taken away from this?  That a community in which 80% (at a minimum!) of the people can be expected to embrace a god of some sort wouldn't take their most painful time to put atheists out in front to help them deal with the situation?  This is, what, some sort of sign that atheists feel nothing when something like this happens?  

People who attack atheists in this way have a blind spot that makes me sad.  This belief that atheists just sit around having no moral code, stealing, killing, doing whatever they want but feeling nothing one way or the other about what happens is, frankly, juvenile.  If Dinesh D'Souza honestly believes this, he has no business writing a column that people with an IQ above 50 might read.  

Apparently D'Souza updated his blog post, energized by all the atheists he's irritated.  He continues:

One clever writer informs me that atheists don't deny meaning, they simply insist that meaning is not inherent in the universe, it is created by us. Okay, pal, here's the Virginia Tech situation. Go create some meaning and share it with the rest of us Give us that atheist sermon with you in the pulpit of the campus chapel. I'm not being facetious here. I really want to hear what the atheist would tell the grieving mothers.

So you think that since atheists won't refer to a god, they can't comfort people?  You know, I lost someone in my family recently.  Others in the family were significantly closer to this person than I was, and they're suffering unbelievable grief as a result of the loss.  And, atheists all of us, we've managed to comfort one another with love and understanding - as any humans should be able to do.  Sure, it'd be nice to say "he's in a better place," or "God has a plan for him," but it wouldn't be true, and it wouldn't make them feel better.  The person they love is still gone.  

D'Souza's line of reasoning not only fails to understand atheists and atheism to an astonishing degree, but it shows a shocking failure to understand grief.  These grieving parents, siblings, friends, and lovers aren't looking for God - they're just looking for comfort.  Those who are religious will undoubtedly turn to their faith for comfort, and it's good that they do.  To suggest that no atheists were lost this week, or that no atheists lost someone at VT, is statistically nonsense.  Those people, too, want and will receive comfort, but in different ways.  When helping those who are suffering this burden this week, one would do just as well to hold them and say "There, there.  There, there."  The grieving aren't listening to your words of "comfort"...they just need the contact.  I think between atheists and D'Souza, the unfeeling one seems to be D'Souza - because no one who legitimately feels, in their heart and soul, the pain of this tragedy would actually write what he decided to write yesterday.

Luckily, I don't have to defend atheism ('cause I'm a crappy writer and don't do it well) in this case, because an actual professor at Virginia Tech has done so, and in the process wrote one of the most beautiful and moving explanations of the atheist understanding of life I've ever seen.  Rather than bother with any more of my nonsense, I'll leave you with some choice quotes - please read the whole thing.

I am to be found in Lane Stadium, looking out over a sea of maroon and orange, trying not to break down when someone mentions the inviolability of the classroom and the bond between a teacher and his students. That is my classroom, Mr D'Souza, my students, my chosen responsibility in this godless life, my small office in the care of humanity and its youth.

I know that brutal death can come unannounced into any life, but that we should aspire to look at our approaching death with equanimity, with a sense that it completes a well-walked trail, that it is a privilege to have our stories run through to their proper end. I don't need to live forever to live once and to live completely. It is precisely because I don't believe there is an afterlife that I am so horrified by the stabbing and slashing and tattering of so many lives around me this week, the despoliation and ruination of the only thing each of us will ever have.

We atheists do not believe in gods, or angels, or demons, or souls that endure, or a meeting place after all is said and done where more can be said and done and the point of it all revealed. We don't believe in the possibility of redemption after our lives, but the necessity of compassion in our lives. We believe in people, in their joys and pains, in their good ideas and their wit and wisdom. We believe in human rights and dignity, and we know what it is for those to be trampled on by brutes and vandals. We may believe that the universe is pitilessly indifferent but we know that friends and strangers alike most certainly are not. We despise atrocity, not because a god tells us that it is wrong, but because if not massacre then nothing could be wrong.

I am to be found on the drillfield with a candle in my hand. "Amazing Grace" is a beautiful song, and I can sing it for its beauty and its peacefulness. I don't believe in any god, but I do believe in those people who have struggled through pain and found beauty and peace in their religion. I am not at odds with them any more than I am at odds with Americans when we sing the "Star-Spangled Banner" just because I am not American.


That is why we have science, and novels, and friendships, and poetry, and practical jokes, and photography, and a sense of awe at the immensity of time and the planet's natural history, and walks with loved ones along the Huckleberry Trail, and atheist friends who keep kosher because, well just because, and passionate reverence for both those heroes who believed and those who did not, and have all this without needing a god to stitch together the tapestry of life.


Those of us with the slightest shred of deceny do not tell widows to deal with it, to get over it. That the world can be callous is no reason to be so myself. I know that no family could ever get over this loss, that no family should ever be expected to get over this loss -- either by themselves, by religious rhetoricians bearing false platitudes, or by inane political pundits -- but that not getting over the loss does not preclude some other kind of happiness, some other source of joy, at some other time. Not now, not in this moment, not when they have moved on, but only when it comes to them one day, like light dawning slowly.

< This will be short and sweet | Consumers Could Pay 20 Percent More to VISA >
Display: Sort:
is that the Atheist is inclined to show more deference to the religious folks and leaders when tragedy happens. This is one of our endearing qualities. Not competing for followers helps us be so generous.

by Particle Man on Fri Apr 20, 2007 at 11:00:09 AM PST

* 2 none 0 *

Hey, thanks for posting I have indeed missed you here.

This is a lie that's told over and over, that atheists are devoid of meaning, flat, empty.  It's a slander.  

I think of how Bush I said that atheists should not be considered to be citizens.  How easy it is to demonize others.

by noemie maxwell on Sun Apr 22, 2007 at 10:04:40 PM PST

* 3 none 0 *

  and yes, Noemie is one very decent woman - glad she reached out to you.

"The bar for success (in Iraqi)is so low that it is almost buried in the sand." Barack Obama, Sept 12, 2007

by Lietta Ruger on Thu Apr 26, 2007 at 11:52:54 AM PST

* 4 none 0 *

Display: Sort:









Seattle Port Commission
Environmental Issues






Challenging the Corporate Media Blockade

Watch Live or Archived Shows:
Seattle SCAN
South End PSA


Photo courtesy of photographer/thankyoult.org




Inspired by Rob McKenna's Fake Attorney General Letterhead
GIF of Letter





Make a new account


Recommended Diaries

Related Links

+ Switzerblo g
+ switzerblog's Diary

Washblog RSS Feeds

Local Media

Coastal/Grays Harbor
Aberdeen Daily World
Chinook Observer
Montesano Vidette
Pacific County Press
Willapa Harbor Herald
KXRO 1320 AM

Olympic Peninsula
Peninsula Daily News
Bremerton Sun
Bremerton Chronicle
Gig Harbor Gateway
Port Orchard Independent
Port Townsend Leader
North Kitsap Herald
Squim Gazette
Central Kitsap Reporter
Business Examiner
KONP 1450 AM

Sound and Islands
Anacortes American
Bainbridge Review
Voice Of Bainbridge
San Juan Journal
The Islands' Sounder
Whidbey NewsTimes
South Whidbey Record
Stanwood/Camano News
Vashon Beachcomber
Voice Of Vashon
KLKI 1340 AM

North Puget Sound
Bellingham Herald
The Northern Light
Everett Herald
Skagit Valley Herald
Lynden Tribune
The Enterprise
Snohomish County Tribune
Snohomish County Business Journal
The Monroe Monitor
The Edmonds Beacon
KELA 1470 AM
KRKO 1380 AM

Central Puget Sound
King County Journal
Issaquah Press
Mukilteo Beacon
Voice of the Valley
Federal Way Mirror
Bothell/Kenmore Reporter
Kirkland courier
Mercer Island Reporter
Woodinville Weekly

Greater Seattle
Seattle PI
Seattle Times
UW Daily
The Stranger
Seattle Weekly
Capitol Hill Times
Madison Park Times
Seattle Journal of Commerce
NW Asian Weekly
West Seattle Herald
North Seattle Herald-Outlook
South Seattle Star
Magnolia News
Beacon Hill News
KOMO AM 1000
KEXP 90.3 FM
KUOW 94.9 FM
KVI 570 AM

South Puget Sound
The Columbian
Longview Daily News
Nisqually Valley News
Lewis County News
The Reflector
Eatonville Dispatch
Tacoma News Tribune
Tacoma Weekly
Puyallup Herald
Enumclaw Courier-Herald
The Olympian
KAOS 89.3 FM
KOWA FM 106.5
UPN 11

Ellensburg Daily Record
Levenworth Echo
Cle Elum Tribune
Snoqualmie Valley Record
Methow Valley News
Lake Chelan Mirror
Omak chronicle
The Newport Miner

The Spokesman-Review
KREM 2 TV Spokane
KXLY News 4 Spokane
KHQ 6 Spokane
KSPS Spokane
Othello Outlook
Cheney Free Press
Camas PostRecord
The South County sun
White Salmon Enterprise
Palouse Boomerang
Columbia Basin Herald
Grand Coulee Star
Walla Walla Union-Bulletin
Yakima Herald-Republic
KIMA 29 Yakima
KAPP TV 35 Yakima
KYVE Yakima
Wenatchee World
Tri-City Herald
TVEW TV 42 Tri-cities
KTNW Richland
KEPR 19 Pasco
Daily Sun News
Prosser Record-Bulletin
KTCR 1340 AM
KWSU Pullman
Moscow-Pullman Daily News

Democracy for Washington tool to email legislators by committee
WA House
WA Senate

Medicine Takeback Program
Return unwanted and expired medications for free and safe disposal.