What's Wrong with the Governor's Education Proposal?
Yesterday Governor Gregoire announced a proposal to spend $197 million to improve the teaching of math and science in middle and high school classrooms. As the Seattle Times has reported, the proposal flows directly out of the recent Washington Learns report. If we are to believe the Times, the proposal is enjoying support from Republicans and Democrats, the business community, a University of Washington professor, and even the Washington Education Association (WEA). Never mind that on the radio this morning I heard a WEA spokesman qualify his support by stating that all classrooms should be reduced in size. Everyone is happy with the plan!
Everyone, that is, but me. I reserve the same skepticism I had when I wrote my previous diary a few days ago. The Washington Learns report privileges math, science and technology above all other considerations, and the governor's recent proposal reflects that report, as echoed in the Times:
The proposal, which attaches dollar amounts to her Washington Learns report, was welcomed by various legislators, the state teachers union and the Washington Roundtable, a business-oriented advocacy group, although they differed on some of the details. One of my central theses was that the governor's education policy was designed to be sellable, and the accolades I'm hearing from various quarters only confirm my views. The Seattle P-I makes much of how the proposed spending will address the dismal WASL scores in math and science. In other words, the additional spending is meant to address the greatest need in the public education system, as measured by the WASL. I see several problems here. I would be more hopeful if I thought the Washington Learns recommendations would lead to serious consideration of all the other pressing needs in K-12 public education. The justification of increased spending on math and science comes, in part, from WASL scores. However, there is a great deal of debate about the legitimacy of those scores. I don't have enough information to assess the math and sciences scores, but I can say a word or two about the writing scores, which are coming out higher. I recently asked an 11th-grader what the writing test was when he was a 10th-grader. He said that on two successive days they were given a prompt to which they were to respond with a hand-written essay within a limited amount of time. I don't know exactly what criteria was used to score these essays, but about a year ago I took a similar test, the West-B Basic Skills tests. In the interests of full disclosure, I'll tell you how I scored: out of a possible 300, I scored 291 on math; 285 on reading; and 283 on writing. In other words, I did best on my worst subject and worst on my best subject. This shouldn't be surprising. For almost my entire adult life, I've written or taught writing in one capacity or another. The test that was being used to judge my writing had nothing to do with most of the writing that I've done in the real world. Ask yourself how often you are required to write an essay on, say, the question of whether junk food should be allowed in school. You have to write it by hand, without a dictionary. You have a half-hour to do it, and no one is allowed to give you editorial feedback. Moreover, you have to write it in five paragraphs, because that's what is typically expected, and you must include a thesis sentence as the last sentence of the first paragraph. Your second, third and fourth paragraphs must provide support for your thesis, and you must close with a summary in the fifth paragraph. I don't know about you, but I only write such essays when I have to take a writing test. Last year, I also took the ETS English Language Literature, Composition and Content Knowledge test, which is a more sophisticated multiple-choice test. I scored 199 out of 200 (what did I miss?). It would be easy for me to conclude the ETS test was a better measure of writing ability. However, I don't really believe that. In my experience, the best way to measure students' writing ability is to give them extended writing projects that simulate the kinds of writing they'll have to do in college and the real world. If you want to impose a writing graduation requirement, then I would have students write a senior thesis, as they do at Northwest School. To institute a portfolio system for graduation requirements would require a serious restructuring of our public education system. Tony Wagner's book Making the Grade: Reinventing America's Schools is replete with examples of school districts around the country that have successfully implemented a portfolio system, but we won't see that system implemented here in Washington State except, perhaps, as a fallback for students who've failed the WASL twice. The reason it won't be implemented here is because the state legislature is so heavily invested in the WASL, the kind of "high-stakes" test whose effectiveness as a graduation requirement has long been challenged by academic studies.
The second impediment to restructuring our public education system in ways that benefit all students is the education policy set forth in the Washington Learns report. As we now see, the report's recommendations are already being turned into legislative proposals, and the political class in this state is coalescing around a consensus that will be difficult to challenge, in a serious way, for the foreseeable future. When you have the business community, Republican and Democratic legislators, the governor, and even the WEA all embracing the same proposal, you are very much a voice crying in the wilderness if you pipe up and say, "Hey--what about funding for social studies, reading and writing, foreign languages, students with special needs, and the arts?"
What's Wrong with the Governor's Education Proposal? | 21 comments (21 topical)
What's Wrong with the Governor's Education Proposal? | 21 comments (21 topical)
|
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
PNW TOPIC HOTLIST |
Recommended Diaries
Recent Diaries
Commissioner Keane now pain free!!
By Dixie (0 comments)
Vote for CHERYL HASKINS, its Common Sense.
By taylor2007 (3 comments)
Domestic Violence Discrimination at METRO
By goforth86 (1 comments)
Lineup set for NW Progressive Convention
By IvyTodd (2 comments)
On Errata, Or, Your Author Apologizes
By fake consultant (4 comments)
Dodd Pledges to Filibuster Telecom Immunity
By The Left Shue (1 comments)
Hand-Counted-Paper -Ballots Rule - in Canada
By bltfsk (12 comments)
Criminal charge against Keane dropped
By Dixie (0 comments)
On Solutions, Or, Congressman Reichert, I Believe You Were Looking For This
By fake consultant (4 comments)
"Coming to a Community Near You: Blackwater"
By bltfsk (1 comments) Washblog RSS FeedsPolitical ContactsLocal MediaAberdeen Daily World Chinook Observer Montesano Vidette Pacific County Press Willapa Harbor Herald KXRO 1320 AM Peninsula Daily News Bremerton Sun Bremerton Chronicle Gig Harbor Gateway Port Orchard Independent Port Townsend Leader North Kitsap Herald Squim Gazette Central Kitsap Reporter Business Examiner KONP 1450 AM Anacortes American Bainbridge Review Voice Of Bainbridge San Juan Journal The Islands' Sounder Whidbey NewsTimes South Whidbey Record Stanwood/Camano News Vashon Beachcomber Voice Of Vashon KLKI 1340 AM Bellingham Herald The Northern Light Everett Herald Skagit Valley Herald Lynden Tribune The Enterprise Snohomish County Tribune Snohomish County Business Journal The Monroe Monitor The Edmonds Beacon KGMI 790 AM KELA 1470 AM KRKO 1380 AM King County Journal Issaquah Press Mukilteo Beacon Voice of the Valley Federal Way Mirror Bothell/Kenmore Reporter Kirkland courier Mercer Island Reporter Woodinville Weekly Seattle PI Seattle Times KOMO TV 4 KIRO TV 7 KING 5 TV KTBW TV 22 KCTS 9 UW Daily The Stranger Seattle Weekly Capitol Hill Times Madison Park Times Seattle Journal of Commerce NW Asian Weekly West Seattle Herald North Seattle Herald-Outlook South Seattle Star Magnolia News Beacon Hill News KIRO 710 AM KOMO AM 1000 KEXP 90.3 FM KUOW 94.9 FM KVI 570 AM The Columbian Longview Daily News Nisqually Valley News Lewis County News The Reflector Eatonville Dispatch Tacoma News Tribune Tacoma Weekly Puyallup Herald Enumclaw Courier-Herald The Olympian KAOS 89.3 FM KCPQ 13 KOWA FM 106.5 UPN 11 Ellensburg Daily Record Levenworth Echo Cle Elum Tribune Snoqualmie Valley Record Methow Valley News Lake Chelan Mirror Omak chronicle The Newport Miner The Spokesman-Review KREM 2 TV Spokane KXLY News 4 Spokane KHQ 6 Spokane KSPS Spokane Statesman-Examiner Othello Outlook Cheney Free Press Camas PostRecord The South County sun White Salmon Enterprise Palouse Boomerang Columbia Basin Herald Grand Coulee Star Walla Walla Union-Bulletin Yakima Herald-Republic KIMA 29 Yakima KAPP TV 35 Yakima KYVE Yakima Wenatchee World Tri-City Herald TVEW TV 42 Tri-cities KTNW Richland KEPR 19 Pasco Daily Sun News Prosser Record-Bulletin KTCR 1340 AM KWSU Pullman Moscow-Pullman Daily News
|